People were worried when Mastodon went from 20,000 to 500,000 people too. I don't see why you would think 1mil -> 2mil to be any different. I really don't agree with the comments that suggest that Mastodon shouldn't grow.
A lot of folks' fear is that when Mastodon grows it'll absorb bad people. I'm gonna say this. I think even if Mastodon literally grows to the size of current Twitter, the world will be better off overall just because of how Mastodon is structured and what values it represents and what tools it provides for dealing with those problems.
@Gargron elitism at its finest
@Gargron Maybe it's not accurate to say that people don't want Mastodon to grow. Maybe it's more that they don't want it to grow in the direction that Twitter did it.
In my case, I wouldn't want it to grow in the direction of becoming yet another Nazi fest.
There's plenty of communities that we should reach out to that should be welcomed.
Giving a platform to nazis in the name of free speech and inclusion is the US centrist fallacy that we shouldn't fall for.
@Gargron I don't understand people who don't want this to grow.
It is not a "personal club".
@Gargron would love to see mastodon hit at least 100mil tbh. that kind of acceptance of decentralized web would be revolutionary
@Gargron I don't see the worry either, unless the trend is still towards larger and larger instances, rather than more and more instances.
Might be an interesting pair of trends to track: avg size of instances over time, versus number of instances over time.
@Gargron absolutely want it to grow! I think best way might be if it could get and stay in the limelight in news, blogs and discussions. Until it's so big that toots will be directly referenced and embedded and people stop talking about Mastodon, but instead about what's happening on here. Going to only to users directly might be a bit inefficient. Megaphones in the right places could make a big difference
@Gargron I hope my last toot is understandable, I had too little sleep lol
@Gargron i want to boost this infinite times
> I think even if Mastodon literally grows to the size of current Twitter
I can agree with the caveat that it'd be distributed, checked growth
unchecked growth -- well, think of any invasive species
adaptation at certain rates is fantastic
adaptation beyond certain rates, from what I've seen, favors some pretty horrible outcomes :/
@Gargron Yeah, I guess "bad people" will gather in some instances that could be muted by the others.
Imagine Mastodon being ccc.de. They have tools, right?
@Gargron No one seems to really recognise that part of the great thing about Mastodon is that you can pick an instance as per your tastes, moderated as such. The issue with Twitter having bad people is negated on Mastodon by blocking accounts and servers; you aren't trusting only one central moderation team.
@Gargron what tools would prevent an instance of mastodon to be setup specifically for disruption or harassment?
@doolbneerg users can mute instances and instance admins can silence or ban other instances
@slipstream hmm, that is cool, but then it means that everyone needs to be more careful about how they select instances. I jumped on the first that had space.
@doolbneerg at least there's an easy way to move instances now
But it's in any case also much about culture not just software.
the fediverse is a cyber space. The information that are shared have impact on ppl and ppl's behavior.
If we can continue to grow mastodon with mostly progressive ppl it will have in future a stronger cultural influence
Once it catches on to mainstream and many centrists, liberals, etc. get introduced to...well fediverse culture.
And yes there are millions of progressives who haven't joined yet
@Gargron Isn't part of Twitter's issue is that there is extremely poor moderation of 'bad behavior' ? I feel like if Mastodon could maintain some rules, they may not have the same issues as a massive site like twitter.
@gargron the very nature of federation almost certainly guarantees a better ratio of admins and mods to users, with fantastic self-moderation tools per-user.
@Gargron amen! That's the whole beauty I promote when talking about Masto!
@Gargron just joined. I have a couple questions about Mastodon.
@SJNX Hi! What are they?
@Gargron what is the purpose of Mastodon? Is it a Twitter alternative? Just FYI I was shut down by Twitter for libertarian anti big government views. I was never vulgar or indecent.
@Gargron got it.. Thanks buddy
@SJNX You were shut down by Twitter for libertarian anti big government views??? Ah! They should kick off Trump then...😏 En plus, il EST vulgaire et indécent!
@Gargron I'd like to understand this; from a few months of use I don't understand yet. I don't think choosing an instance is it because you can't move.
.@Gargron Not to mention the incentives for dealing with problems.
@Gargron that and also you’re a better human being than Jack Dorsey. But that’s not saying much any decent human is better than Jack Dorsey.
@Gargron Thank you for creating this platform for people like us who want to escape the drama over there and just let us have a place to be welcomed.
@Gargron I see the worst thing happening is spamming, and name squatting.
but email systems showed us how we can handle that. Domain blocks lists (CBLs) are already becoming a thing in Mastodon, for example.
@Gargron I think as a community we should acknowledge their fear and make sure they feel heard. That is fundamentally what twitter has failed to do.
From a technical perspective we're not worried about shitlords ruining it but that doesn't mean that people who were traumatized on twitter share our confidence that the new system will protect them.
@foozmeat It's not twitter users who express that sentiment.
@Gargron I see.
We need to be able to sort of culturate the influx, I think.
We can see historical breakdowns in usenet's eternal september.
I can't help but wonder what the critical mass is one way or the other
I think because mastodon is /so/ distributed though, it has a much higher critical threshold before disintegration kicks in.
Is it even possible for a company to sustain a user-friendly model long term?
Users might also be willing to pay more for media uploads/downloads, opening up market for media-less instances (that likely cost less).
@Gargron Eugen, would you mind sharing the current numbers and growth rate? I'd like to get an idea how big / popular Mastodon currently is - out of personal curiosity.
@naii Active users since 2.1.2 release: https://dashboards.instances.social/dashboard/db/network-activity?orgId=1 collected by @TheKinrar
Registered users growth: https://dashboards.mnm.social/dashboard/db/user-growth?orgId=1 collected by @eliotberriot
Server run by the main developers of the project It is not focused on any particular niche interest - everyone is welcome as long as you follow our code of conduct!