Follow

PSA: If you do use browser, be aware it doesn't block or trackers

For Facebook tracking Brave white-lists
connect.facebook.net
connect.facebook.com
staticxx.facebook.com
www.facebook.com
scontent.xx.fbcdn.net
pbs.twimg.com
scontent-sjc2-1.xx.fbcdn.net

According to Brave developers, it's white-listed due to causing Facebook login to break if blocked.

See issue #1108 on Github
github.com/brave/brave-browser…

@wuwei @Rastal doesn't #Brave make its money by selectively whitelisting ads? For that reason Brave is inherently a bad tool for #privacy.

@resist1984

Haven't heard something about that

I do know however know a lot of funding is coming from their cryptocurrency that is funded by them filling sites with their own ads.
It includes replacing actual ads as well as apparently adding them to some addfree sites

@Rastal

@wuwei @Rastal the two under-handed ways that ad-blockers profit is by whitelisting ads that pay the ad blocker not to block, and indeed the non-whitelisted ads are often replaced by ads that benefit the ad blocking project. I knew Brave made use of one or both of those schemes but didn't recall which.

@resist1984 @wuwei @Rastal I don't see the problem with this. They replace bad ads with simple ones that don't track. And that's an option. I also understand not breaking fb login. I'm guessing firefox does this as well since I can use fb on it.

@jordan31 @Rastal @wuwei I'm not sure if Brave is transparent about that. If not, certainly there's a problem w/deception. Users believe they're getting ad blocking, but they're getting ad replacement shenanigans instead.

@wuwei @Rastal @jordan31 also, the user has no duty to accept ads (targeted or not), and no duty to ensure a suppliers business is profitable. There are non-profit efforts to block as many ads as possible and those are the most ethical (noting that advertising is an arms race we need not accept).

@jordan31
Firefox does it differently, Firefox allows users different levels of tracking protection, they can choose standard, stricter or customize it.
@resist1984 @wuwei

@resist1984 @wuwei @Rastal to me they are the only ones really putting forth an effort for ads to be a thing but safe. Kind of appeasing both sides while people make money.

@Rastal

You should use uBlock Origin with "Anti-Facebook List" instead

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Mastodon

Server run by the main developers of the project 🐘 It is not focused on any particular niche interest - everyone is welcome as long as you follow our code of conduct!