@Shamar @TheGibson

In Clause 3.4 (in "Conditions"), what is the definition or "runtime"? I am thinking of the use case where you need to buy a proprietary compiler for a bare-bones processor. It is off-the-shelf but it is not an operating system (bare bones), and technically a compiler is not a runtime. Could you clarify this?

@Shamar @TheGibson

I'm sorry, that is still not clear enough. It hinges on the definition of "runtime", so I think that term should be defined or even expanded.

In the case of a bare-bones embedded system, what constitutes a "runtime"?

Usually a runtime is a set of libraries that come with the compiler. So it is in that sense part of the required off-the-shelf distribution, but usually one would call that a development kit, not an OS or runtime.

@Shamar @TheGibson

There is no catch.
If I understand it correctly, under your license it is OK that users have to pay for the OS or runtime but not for anything else. Is that correct?

@Shamar @TheGibson

OK, that is clear. I think it is reasonable because users nad hackers need an OS anyway, and you don't want to exclude those who use a proprietary OS. Maybe you could make this rationale a bit more explicit.

It just means that for some of my work I would not be able to use this license. That's OK, there are plenty of other suitable licenses.

Follow

@thegibson

Hi guys, I've updated the preamble and added a definitions of runtime to the .

Would you mind to give a look to the new version? tesio.it/documents/HACK.txt

In particular, @wim_v12e, I tried to clarify your doubts about the runtime in embedded systems: do you think the wording is better now?

I proposed it for discussion on Debian Legal, maybe you might find it interesting.
lists.debian.org/debian-legal/

Please don't be shy to propose improvements.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Mastodon

Follow friends and discover new ones. Publish anything you want: links, pictures, text, video. This server is run by the main developers of the Mastodon project. Everyone is welcome as long as you follow our code of conduct!