We had ads on sites.
Then we had ad-blockers against ads on sites.
Then came the ad-blocker-blockers on sites.
And now: we block ad-blockers inside the browser…
@zalandocalrissian I once bought Opera to remove them. Ad Blocking by money.
(Should reconsider this, maybe still an option 🤔)
@bkastl Merely another round of browser makers being ambivalent about whether they should embrace or reject add-ons. On the one side, add-ons (particularly ad blockers ) provide a great deal of value and drive adoption. On the other hand, they can degrade performance and open up security issues.
@bkastl webRequest API was introduced back when Chrome was still playing catchup with Firefox and getting a decent ad blocker was essential to compete. Now that Chrome succeeded and forced Mozilla to dumb down their extension APIs, there is much less pressure to keep it available. Even though webRequestDeclarative would degrade functionality of all ad blockers, who cares if it is already much degraded compared to what Firefox had to offer some years ago?
@WPalant @bkastl Personally, it was Firefox Quantum, when we lost the full power of extensions. (The DRM, at least, doesn't *ship* with Firefox and isn't enabled by default. Kind of an academic point, I admit.)
But I don't think we've quite reached the breaking point as a community. Techies are still, by and large, willing to say "we must use/support only the main 3 browsers" and haven't been willing to jump off to more user-embracing alternatives. Or even use Firefox, FFS.
@varx @bkastl Firefox Quantum took years of preparation. All the while I've been talking to Mozilla staff on all levels, making various points, asking for corrections. All to no avail, Mozilla was going to settle on the feature set of Chromium and nothing I said mattered.
I don't blame them, this was an act of desperation. But the end result is: techies no longer matter. They are too small of a group, no browser maker cares about their needs today.
@brandon in Chrome it's more or less an implementation of the betterads approach: https://clearcode.cc/blog/chrome-built-in-ad-blocker/
Firefox is more of a tracking blocker.
@bkastl that's why you might use Brave. Integrated AdBlocking. It is a chromium fork but they declared this week that they are not affected by manifest v3 since they tailor the base product the way they need it. Btw. AntiTracking, https-upgrades etc included.
Server run by the main developers of the project It is not focused on any particular niche interest - everyone is welcome as long as you follow our code of conduct!