Follow

Huge Star Trek fan here, but I got to say: The Orville is better than all the recent Star Trek franchises I've seen.

You can roast me now.

@Alumina Not yet, supposedly it'll air on Dec 30th this year.

Just finishing up season 1 and I wish there were like five more seasons to binge watch right now.

@fribbledom More Orville soon? Excellent! One of my favorites was the "planet of the social media." It was right on target.

@fribbledom I don't know about better. But it's more fun, and I love that. :)

@fribbledom No roasting needed. I love The Orville too. "If the Stars Should Appear" (S01E04) is one of my favorite episodes of last season.

@mookie

Probably my favorite, too. I also liked S01E07 "Majority Rule", it felt like a crossover between Star Trek and Black Mirror.

@fribbledom I like star trek (TNG) and I despise Seth McFarland but damn if I don't thoroughly enjoy the Orville

@fribbledom Couldn’t agree more. I tried watching the first season of Discovery and just couldn’t go on.

@fribbledom Make room on the spit. The Orville has unexpected warmth and soul. And over time, there's less of the outright silly stuff, which I welcome.

Frankly, a much stronger season 1 than TNG. ;)

@fribbledom No roasting, just agreement!

The Orville seems like it was made by fans of Star Trek, most recent official Trek seems like it was made by fans of Star Wars.

@fribbledom Is it episodic? That's what I liked best about TNG and even Voyager. Discovery wanted to be some kind of.. War Story thing and not episodic...

@maverynthia

Much like TNG it got a rough continuous storyline, but you can still enjoy each episode individually, as they have their own arc of suspense.

@fribbledom some of the humour early on doesn't land for me, but in many ways it seems to have the heart of TNG

@fribbledom I would mostly agree to that except I quite like Discovery.

@der_Jeff I do like Discovery, too. It just doesn't quite feel right in the Star Trek universe, though.

@fribbledom that's because it's more like a serial which, in my opinion, is what makes it enjoyable. I prefer that over the "forehead of the week" format. Makes for more in depth story lines.

@fribbledom I'm with you on this. It's got a lot of heart and love for TNG and Rob Lowe.

@fribbledom Same here.
When watching season one I kept thinking how awesome it must be for Seth McFarlane to be able to make this. It is unmistakably his own creation but it's also a loving hommage to Star Trek, which he seems to be a great fan of. It gets even better with the involvement of former Star Trek cast members. I'm eagerly looking forward to watching season two.

@fribbledom
Fortunately they're working together! I've seen a photo of Marina Sirtis and Johnathan Frakes on the Orville set!

@fribbledom
1) Seth MacFarlane as a real actor instead of a cartoon is interesting
2) leave it to Seth to challenge a franchise and copywrite
3) its a comedic sort of startrek - something new - reminds me of spaceballs

@fribbledom
Fellow trekkie here. The Orville is really awesome. Especially compared to all the crap since JJ Trek. And don't get me started on this discovery atrocity. I hope there will be more Orville in the future.

@fribbledom There's a lot to like about it, but I kept feeling the insertion of lowbrow humor was rather gratuitous. A pity, as the writers tend to have a good grasp of their characters, with storylines a good bit less staid than, say, TNG often wound up with.

B5 hit the balance perfectly, for me - silly at times, but it /flowed/ well in context; with O, it more feels like the writers've concluded they need a lewd joke to keep the audience interested.

@porsupah @fribbledom If by "better" you mean a better window into Seth MacFarlane psycho-sexual hangups, of which there seem to be many.

@fribbledom It’s true. I’m an advocate that Seth Macfarlane should be given the Star Trek franchise to run.

@fribbledom
I really like The Orville, too!

It was the antidote to all the ways Discovery rubbed me the wrong way during the first half of the season. Though I think Discovery stepped it up as the season went on where The Orville only made minor improvements.
("Firestorm" really showed their true potential, though).

I'm every bit as excited for both to come back at the end of the year, though!

@fribbledom agreed! even in its clumsiest moments it’s more enjoyable too.

@fribbledom *lights fire* What do you call recent? ST Enterprise? Or only ST Discovery? Films don't count.

@Ronald

Yeah, Enterprise and Discovery. Loved TNG, TOS & Voyager, took me some time to warm up to DS9.

@fribbledom I've seen them all at least 3 times. Just finished rewatching ENT, which is dearly underestimated in my opinion. DS9 is my favorite, but in fact I love them all. Discovery was nice, but I have to see it again to have a real opinion. And about the Orville: it's Star Trek and yet it isn't. It's funny though.

@fribbledom I am cocksure it aint really Star Trek if it is after Voyager. Though I don't write articles or do like a video presentation or anything to argue this point specifically.

@fribbledom i wont roast you, but it isn’t the best. Till my dying day I will go to the mattresses that DS9 is the greatest Trek. The Orville is right behind it.

@venkuskirata With "recent franchises" I really meant Discovery and Enterprise. TOS, TNG, DS9 & Voyage were all pretty awesome.

@fribbledom hahaha I like The Orville, but ST:Discovery is great, too.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Mastodon

Invite-only Mastodon server run by the main developers of the project 🐘 It is not focused on any particular niche interest - everyone is welcome as long as you follow our code of conduct!