Mr. Incredible is a user on mastodon.social. You can follow them or interact with them if you have an account anywhere in the fediverse. If you don't, you can sign up here.

@Laurelai It amazes me how emotional people get about blockchain. I have yet to see a sober evaluation of blockchain tech that concluded that it was never useful.

@seanl @Laurelai I've yet to comprehend just what magic it's supposed to do anyway. what problem was a "blockchain" supposed to solve

@kara @Laurelai It's a means of achieving a single agreed upon ordering of transactions without needing a trusted third party. That way, if someone tries to spend the same money to person A and person B, there's an algorithmic means of determining which is the valid transaction.

@kara @Laurelai There are lots of criticisms like "it's not really decentralized because of pool mining" and "it's easy to attack because you don't really need a majority of hashing power" and "it'll destroy the planet because it uses too much energy". The first hasn't been a problem in practice; the incentives for miners are "better" than the incentives for central banks. For the second I say "well then feel free to go make your billions breaking it".

@kara @Laurelai Bitcoin has the largest bug bounty in history by several orders of magnitude. And the third one I've addressed before but it boils down to the fact that the electricity must be paid for by some combination of transaction fees and block rewards, so it has to grow far more slowly than the transaction rate in the long run, but that there will also be technological advancements to reduce it.

@kara @Laurelai Of course, I was extrapolating a lot from one image. 99.9% of the time if someone is asking if they need a blockchain the answer is indeed "no". And if they're a startup it's like 99.9999% of the time.

@kara @Laurelai There's a second really interesting application of blockchain for which nobody has come up with a better solution, which is assigning human-meaningful, globally unique names to things. For that you either need a central or hierarchical authority or a blockchain.