J# is a user on mastodon.social. You can follow them or interact with them if you have an account anywhere in the fediverse. If you don't, you can sign up here.

Mastodonnas: The following thread is for the benefit of Twitter users. Forgive me, because you already know this stuff.

(Trivia: I’m tooting all this on a Virgin Atlantic flight to London. Imagine a plane tooting its way through the air 💨💨💨✈️ like farts, but with the emoji facing left, dammit.

Having said that, I have no idea which way the emoji face on your platform.)


Twitter users: let’s talk about why Mastodon’s nice.

This is a Mastodon toot. Unlike a Twitter tweet, there’s room for up to 500 characters.
It may not seem like a huge difference, but after Twitter, it’s like standing up straight after being bent over in a low-ceilinged room for 10 years.

Even after typing this line, I still have room left over for an entire tweet.

Oh, the complete thoughts I can express!


Twitter threads were always a terrible idea. You may have read some great ones, but face it. It’s like a terrible squinty version of Bob Dylan’s “Subterranean Homesick Blues” video, about as accessible, usually makes even less sense. Lines get broken up, and misunderstood, and you get replies to fragments. You Don’t Need A URL For Every Half-Sentence.

In a Mastodon thread, every message in a thread can be a complete paragraph. A whole thought. Oh my god, I can read again.


(I hate, hate, HATE the way that Twitter makes it so easy to take words out of context, the length forcing you to take you complex thoughts and whittle them down until they’re sharp spikes ready to go into your own foot - Twitter has broken down all barriers to communication and caused More And Bloodier Wars than any other social network in the history of creation.)


Not only is Mastodon open source, but its creator - the wonderful (and currently really stressed) @Gargron - actually cares about UX, actually cares about community, and is encouraging the creation of new clients. We can add new features, plugins, whatever. There’s room for a galaxy here.

Remember when there were more than 5 decent Twitter clients? Remember when Twitter cared about being a developer platform? Those were the days.


Five toots in and I’m only now mentioning federation, because while many others are banging on about that - and yes, it’s really important - it’s *not* the reason for Mastodon taking off. We’ve had federated microblogging protocols for years now, and Mastodon is the latest of many projects to use them. But Mastodon’s the first that this many people wanted to use.

Federation’s not why this rocket’s taking off, but it *may* get it into orbit.


Right now, Mastodon’s community is in its salad days: enough people for it to be exciting, small enough to not suffer too much. But everyone knows what’s coming if it gets big.

This is where the open source & federated nature really comes into play. I’m not saying Mastodon can easily solve all the ugly harassment & other problems that Twitter hasn’t, but it has a much better shot - especially now that the users build and run the platform.


@yoz how does federation solve harassment? Is it because it's open source and federated, we can fork and try to build our own solutions as opposed to just leaving? Or is there more to it?

@joshsharp That's a big part of it, yes. But be clear: I'm not saying it *solves* harassment, just gives us many more options for dealing with it. There's still going to be plenty of noise and pain, and some of it's going to take whole new ugly forms that weren't possible before.

J# @joshsharp

@yoz agreed. As far as I can see, it's a double-edged sword. More control just means higher-stakes cat-and-mouse — more we can do to fix it, but many more new and undiscovered ways to harass people. Still, better than the alternative, I think.

· Web · 0 · 1