Is the Whonix project run by fascists? https://micahflee.com/2020/06/is-the-whonix-project-run-by-fascists/
@micahflee minor remark: no, on Mastodon "Tweets" aren't called toots. ActivityPub "notes" or microblog entries are called toots.
Mastodon is not a Twitter clone and has outgrown that initiative these days. Maybe a better way to put it would be "toots on Mastodon are comparable to Tweets on Twitter". I think the statement makes it sound like Mastodon would be cheap Twitter copy, which both of us know, it's not. Thanks :)
@sheogorath very true, it was just the simplest way to quickly describe a "toot" in a parenthetical statement :)
@Johnny_of_the_swamp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gab_(social_network) "Co-founder and CEO Andrew Torba has cited 'the entirely left-leaning Big Social monopoly' and an alleged bias against conservative articles by Facebook as his reasons for creating the site." lol
@Johnny_of_the_swamp I think the point is that what should be a non-political software project aligning itself with a pro-hate-speech platform is not ideal.
@Johnny_of_the_swamp > Last I checked Richard Spencer is still on Twitter.
That is a con for Twitter, which is almost as bad, sure, not a pro for Gab. Twitter is already a cesspool, imagine what a platform of people that had to be 'booted off' it is going to look like lol
oh wait, while I'm writing this, I remember you engaged on exactly this topic already with me.
I pointed out to you that your community members support Gab.
You responded with ridiculizing me.
Have you changed your mind?
People of your community gave/give support to Gab and so to facism.
Confront it, or be confronted!
@syster PrivacyTools is a diverse group of people that all work hard to promote online privacy, even if I don’t agree with everyone’s opinions all the time. And if they choose to share them on their own time and personal accounts who am I to stop them? It’s a volunteer-based project, not some sort of employment.
1. no, it's not very diverse. It contains mostly out of liberal white cis dudes.
2. you are giving support to Gab-supporter on the base, that they share resources with privacytools.io. That is concering to me.
@syster > It contains mostly out of liberal white cis dudes.
again - what do you want me to do about this then?
1. that you listen to concerns that are related to discrimination and that you take them seriously, even more when it is linked to fascism.
2. that you take position against discrimination, even more when it is linked to fascism.
3. that you will never play again the "but they have supported that project, so I don't call them out/in" card.
4. that there will be reflection about your and your communities whiteness (it's not about your skin color, it's about an ideology, that if you have never identified as such, you'll be reproducing it.)
5. that there will be reflection about free software being political and what it means if this political sphere is open to fascism.
6. that action will result from this reflection
I found the beginning of that chat. If you have a matrix account, you can find it here:
If you don't, I can copy/paste that for you.
@micahflee I don’t need Whonix, but your quote, together with Ed’s, made me want to try it a couple of months back. Done with that idea now. Glad you wrote this.
@mewmew how so? why else would the people who run Whonix choose to lose so much support rather than changing their mind about their neo-Nazi social media presence?
@mewmew then perhaps they would explain that point of view to everyone asking them wtf. But instead they silently ignore these questions and lose support from antifascists
@mewmew I didn't, that's why there was a question mark in the headline. It leaves open the possibility that they're not fascists, though they also quite likely are
@micahflee Why should it matter, as long as the code does its job? Are you suggesting considering politics over operational security?
First, yes human rights and fighting fascism is more important than operational security. Obviously. You're ok with associating with Nazis?
But also, Whonix isn't the only option. It's possible to torify VMs without it. Whonix is complicated and heavy, and I think there are better implemented ways of doing the same thing
@micahflee While I agree fighting fascism is important, I'd argue that a person in need of secure comms wouldn't think twice about using any software that gets the job done, and done well. But indeed, if the person had the luxury of time & choice they should probably choose something else.
> Whonix isn't the only option
Oh, that's great then. Ditch it altogether.
P.S.: I attended your talk at Nullcon and I appreciate your work!
@micahflee What better implemented ways are there of torifying VMs? Have you reached out to the Qubes team because Patrick Schleizer is on their website and development team as well?
@micahflee And so what is the theory you’re drafting here? Whonix is run by Nazis, who apparently strictly approve of Jews that are serial rapists, in an effort to rebuild the Fourth Reich?
@retroartdt I'm not drafting a theory, I'm pointing out disturbing and problematic behavior within in an important free software project.
(And Nazis are fine with Jews that share their worldview. Just look at Stephen Miller, a Jewish Nazi in the White House)
So, because 1 person doesn't respond to emails about the very same subject and you concluded that gab is a fascist network, you then conclude that he must be a fascist (singular btw) too?
Whonix's 'follow' category contains a whopping 17 links, including Twitter, Facebook and YouTube, but you're not reporting on their problematic relation to privacy/freedom/democracy?
Or is that because TheIntercept is on there too and not on freedom respecting platforms?
Bit hypocritical imo.
- I don't like gab. Mostly because they take FOSS and rebrand it to make it look it's their own work and don't give back (afaik). Normally I give ppl the benefit of the doubt, but not with gab users.
Whonix likely receives a constant barrage of email wrt their gab presence. Therefor them not responding isn't all that weird. And no proof of fascists sympathies.
- I like/support TheIntercept and link to their articles quite often. Their absence on FOSS platforms annoys me thou
My blog post about Whonix doesn't have anything to do with and isn't related to The Intercept.
Gab is a social network for fascists. I didn't conclude Patrick is fascist, I just pointed out problematic and fascism sympathizer behavior -- he clearly cares more about protecting Whonix's association with fascists than he does about the Whonix project.
While Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, etc all have terrible qualities, and Nazis use them, none of them are designed for and by neo-Nazis.
I know it was on your personal title (and site).
I'm aware that gab has a disturbing number of users with disturbing ideologies; hence them not getting the benefit of doubt.
I do not think that all gab users are fascists or it is meant (solely) for fascists (an elephant is an animal, not all animals are elephants).
Explain to me how "Is the Whonix project run by fascists?" and Patrick runs the project, does not lead to the conclusion that Patrick is a fascist?
The reason I mentioned Twitter/FB/YT and TheIntercept was to point out that presence on a network does not equate to endorsing that platform.
Even though it does strengthen that platform. Especially if that's the only way to get in contact or communicate with it.
If Whonix had only 1 link (to gab), yeah, that would've been problematic in my book (as well). But it's 1 of 17 and that does make a difference to me.
@FreePietje it's unclear whether or not Patrick is fascist, and when he gets asked about his problematic behavior, rather than explaining himself ("I think Gab is just a free speech site not a fascist site", for example) he refuses to give a rational, which makes it seem like maybe he's fascist. But hey, maybe he's not. That's why there's a question mark
Based on https://forums.whonix.org/t/long-wiki-edits-thread/3477/1017 and https://www.whonix.org/wiki/Limitations_on_Free_Speech_on_Whonix_Website_and_Whonix_Chat (found within 5 clicks from your "maybe" link) it is apparent to me that he is strong proponent of free speech. Due to time and legal requirements he has limited it on whonix.org, but hopes that gab.ai can succeed (as it's not a side project).
My guess that he's tired of having to explain himself over and over seems quite plausible.
I still think the fascist accusation is unwarranted.
But heh, free speech and all that ;)
Server run by the main developers of the project It is not focused on any particular niche interest - everyone is welcome as long as you follow our code of conduct!