serious question: why aren't there equivalents to the Persona games set in the United States? (e.g. epic turn-based RPGs about being a teenager set in the present day)

(just thinking about how I've played seemingly countless video games set in Tokyo but few if any games set in New York City. or *any* US city really, other than their apocalyptic versions in e.g. fallout)

@aparrish it strikes me that mainstream US media doesn't really do slice-of-life stuff much, while it's not uncommon in manga so there might be more tolerance for that kind of setting in the Japanese market?

@theoutrider I wasn't even considering the mundane/visual novel aspects of the persona games, just the teenagers-doing-battle aspect. in any case I feel like I can come up with like a gazillion tv shows that have slice-of-life characteristics about teens in the US, though. like, veronica mars is essentially persona 4

@aparrish that's fair - I've never seen VM but the American films and TV and comics I've been exposed to haven't really done it much

I guess soap operas kind of do as well? but they're hamming everything up for the drama and all


@aparrish @bentosmile gave me Love Roma to read a while ago and it's so different in tone from almost any American (or European, really) media I've encountered

like it doesn't really try to stick to any particular tone (say, the way a sitcom does even when it explores character development etc) or anything, it's just consistently a really nice, sincere, low-key thing about teenage relationships

@aparrish like, uh, Malcolm in the Middle has a lot of kind of good depictions of what life is like when you're "just barely managing", but the (admittedly tremendous) layer of slapstick comedy is so thick that the "life" aspect feels almost coincidental

(I'm kind of straining for examples here because I've never thought about this in a lot of detail)

Sign in to participate in the conversation

Follow friends and discover new ones. Publish anything you want: links, pictures, text, video. This server is run by the main developers of the Mastodon project. Everyone is welcome as long as you follow our code of conduct!