“Can I trust app X?”

Can you trust the company/organisation/people who make it? (What have they done in the past/are doing now?)

Can you trust their business model? (How/when do they make money?)

Is it open source?

Is it decentralised?

If yes to all, yes. Otherwise no.

@aral don’t forget: can you trust all potential future owners of the company, its databases and its business partners.

@zensaiyuki @aral that's why open source/free software is not enough, it should be copyleft. then it can't be made proprietary later!


but that only applies to software you run on your own devices. when you give your data to a company, you have to trust them not use it for malicious purposes. with GDPR they have to tell that they do it. open tumblr for example, you get a list of hundreds of partners with whom they share your data and the partners also have partners and so on...

@davidak @aral open source AND copyleft mean nothing without ethical guidelines as well. An oppressive government or evil corporation can leverage copyleft software just as easily as anyone else.

@zensaiyuki @aral yes. my only point is that you can trust copyleft software not to become closed source what can happen with permissive open source licenses. it happen sometimes when a project is sold

@davidak @aral I wouldn’t bet on it. in order for copyleft software to not become closed source, the author must be prepared to sue, and have the money to do so. it’s a license not a magic spell.


@davidak @aral now the EFF does a great job at backing software authors up on such issues but their resources are not unlimited.

@davidak @aral and, also, it’s a legal agreement in a country. entities in foreign countries and foreign governments aren’t particularly bound to honour it.

Sign in to participate in the conversation

Server run by the main developers of the project 🐘 It is not focused on any particular niche interest - everyone is welcome as long as you follow our code of conduct!